Line one: the callback
The tankless flush, the sediment-filled tank, the heater replaced years before its rated life. Paid work, and it comes back on its own schedule for as long as the water stays hard.
Hard water takes a tankless heater from 80 percent efficiency to 72 in a year and a half. Your company already gets paid for what happens next: the flush, the callback, the replacement. What it does not get paid for is preventing it, and the house where the heater just failed is the exact house where that second line is sold.
Today you get paid to replace it. Nobody is getting paid to prevent it.
Short answer
Scale is the mineral that hard water leaves behind when it is heated, and a water heater is where the water gets heated. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, reporting a Battelle study, found a tankless gas heater on hard water fell from 80 percent efficiency to 72 percent in 1.6 years, and a gas storage heater fell from 70.4 to 67.4 over two years. Preventing scale extends appliance life by 25 to 40 percent. The flush, the element, the early replacement: that is the callback line, and your company already runs it. The system that stops the scale is the prevention line, and it is sold standing in front of the heater that just failed.
The tankless flush, the sediment-filled tank, the heater replaced years before its rated life. Paid work, and it comes back on its own schedule for as long as the water stays hard.
The softener or conditioner that stops the scale forming. One install, one maintenance calendar, and a water heater that reaches the end of its rated life. Sold in the same garage, on the same visit, by the same technician.
The numbers
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Tankless gas heater, hard water | Efficiency fell from 80 percent to 72 percent in 1.6 years | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL-22921, 2013), reporting the Battelle study |
| Gas storage heater, hard water | Efficiency fell from 70.4 percent to 67.4 percent over 2 years | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL-22921, 2013), reporting the Battelle study |
| Appliance life, scale prevented | 25 to 40 percent longer | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL-22921, 2013), citing New Mexico State University |
| Hard water, by the USGS bands | 7 to 10.5 grains per gallon; very hard above 10.5 | U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Water Science School |
| Dallas, as published | 120 to 155 mg/L (7.0 to 9.1 gpg); 8 to 12 gpg in field tests | City of Dallas, 2023 memo; Roger Wakefield, field tests |
Eight points of efficiency on a tankless unit in under two years is a warranty call, a callback, and eventually a replacement. The homeowner sees the gas bill and the lukewarm shower. Your technician sees the scale. One grain per gallon is 17.1 milligrams per liter (mg/L).
Line one
A tankless heater on hard water needs flushing, and the harder the water, the sooner. A tank heater on hard water fills with sediment, loses efficiency, and fails early. Every one of those is a call your company already takes, and every one of them puts a technician in the one room in the house where the water heater, the softener loop and the main line all live.
That room is the reason a plumber beats a dealer at this. The dealer has to buy a lead to get into it. You were dispatched there, on a call the homeowner made, about a problem the water caused. The question is whether the technician standing in it knows that the heater is the symptom and can say so in plain language.
Why the invitation is the asset: plumbers vs water treatment dealers.
Line two
A homeowner who just paid to replace a water heater years early is the easiest person in the city to talk to about why it failed. Nobody has to sell them on hardness; the heater did that. What they need is a technician who can test the water at the tap while they watch, read the number out loud, point at the scale, and say what stops it.
That sale ends the callback line in that house and starts a different one: the maintenance calendar on the system, and a water heater that reaches the end of its rated life instead of the middle. The company that installs the system is the one on that calendar, for as long as the homeowner lives there.
The homeowner standing next to a heater that failed early. The hardness is already proven; the invoice for the replacement proved it.
The technician who was there anyway, if he was taught to test the water, name the problem and put a price on fixing it.
One install at HALO's $6,000 to $8,000 range, and the maintenance visits after it. One truck at a 5 percent close rate across 780 calls a year is 39 of these.
What a technician is taught to say and show in the kitchen is day three of the class and is not on this page.
Watch it
The flush is line one. It is paid work, and it will be paid again next year, until somebody sells line two.
Questions
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, reporting a Battelle study, found a tankless gas heater fell from 80 percent efficiency to 72 percent in 1.6 years on hard water, and a gas storage heater fell from 70.4 percent to 67.4 percent over two years.
The same Pacific Northwest National Laboratory report, citing New Mexico State University, puts appliance life 25 to 40 percent longer when scale is prevented.
On the U.S. Geological Survey bands, 7 to 10.5 grains per gallon is hard and above 10.5 is very hard. One grain per gallon is 17.1 milligrams per liter. Dallas publishes 7.0 to 9.1 grains, and Roger Wakefield's own field tests in Dallas homes typically read 8 to 12.
Because the heater failing early is the hardness, proven, with an invoice attached. The technician who replaces it is standing in the right room, in front of the right homeowner, with the evidence. Testing the water at the tap turns the replacement into a diagnosis.
It is paid work, and it comes back on its own. The prevention sale is worth more: one install at HALO's $6,000 to $8,000 range, a maintenance calendar after it, and a customer whose heater reaches the end of its life with your company on the schedule.
Sources
Checked in November 2026. Every efficiency figure is from the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory report; hardness figures are the utility's own.
Keep going
The first class ran in Dallas, November 3-5. The next HALO Water Tour dates are coming soon. Apply now and you'll hear first. Carlsbad returns in early 2027 with the dates announced on the Carlsbad page first.